With Langeliers out for the year and Goodman a long shot, Heyman's updated market leaves New York circling two options. The one worth examining is the Reds catcher who's been quietly hot for two months.
The catching market just got a lot smaller for New York.
Shea Langeliers won't be walking into the Bronx. The A's catcher suffered a torn knee meniscus on Saturday and could miss the rest of the year. But per Jon Heyman of the New York Post, the injury is beside the point for the Yankees: the club had already concluded, before Langeliers went down, that Oakland wasn't going to make him available. Hunter Goodman — the Rockies catcher this desk covered ten days ago when New York first called Colorado — is now described by Heyman as a long shot. That leaves two names: Ryan Jeffers, who has been the subject of this beat since the Arraez talks fizzled on July 23, and Tyler Stephenson, the Cincinnati Reds catcher who hasn't dominated the deadline conversation but may be the most realistic get on the board.
The case for Stephenson starts with the Reds. Cincinnati entered this week at 47-54, sitting 16.5 games behind Milwaukee in the NL Central. Reds president of baseball operations Nick Krall signaled to the Cincinnati Enquirer this week that he plans to retool rather than rebuild — moving rentals and older pieces while preserving the young core around Elly De La Cruz and Chase Burns. Stephenson, earning a $6.8MM salary this season, fits the profile of a piece worth dealing. The demand side is confirmed, too: per MLB Trade Rumors' July 24 deadline outlook on Cincinnati, the Yankees, Rays, Red Sox, and White Sox are all seeking catching upgrades before the August 3 deadline.
The case also starts with the bat — at least the recent version of it. Stephenson had a rough first half, but over his last 135 plate appearances he's hitting .309/.370/.496 with five home runs and eight doubles, a 134 wRC+ per the same MLBTR report. The full-season line — .244/.320/.393, 92 wRC+ — is less convincing. But a catcher trending sharply upward, available from a confirmed seller, with multiple teams lined up behind him is exactly the profile the Yankees need to exploit before time runs out.
The broader context: New York is running an 89 wRC+ since Aaron Judge went down with a rib stress fracture on June 2, fourth-worst in baseball over that stretch. Cody Bellinger just hit the IL with a hamstring strain. The deadline is one week away. The catching market that once included Langeliers, Goodman, Jeffers, and Stephenson has been cut in half, and one of the two survivors depends on whether Minnesota decides to sell.
The Yankees have watched the options close in front of them one by one. Stephenson is what's left — and the Reds are very much open for business.
